What are the Best BIM Tools for Clash Detection?

It can be a nightmare to spend months meticulously planning a construction project to discover costly and time-consuming clashes during the build.

That’s where Building Information Modeling BIM tools for clash detection come in!

In this blog, I will guide you through the best BIM tools that not only spot these clashes but also streamline your entire construction process.

Let’s begin!

Table of Contents

What is BIM Clash Detection?

Clash detection is an integral part of Building Information Modeling (BIM). BIM clash detection finds and resolves clashes between two or more construction models within a virtual setting.

In essence, BIM clash detection scrutinizes different design components like structural elements, HVAC systems, and electrical conduits to identify any overlaps or interference within a virtual model. This highly detailed analysis is invaluable for project managers and structural engineers, allowing them to resolve issues before they escalate into costly and time-consuming problems during construction.

Using BIM clash detection tools like the Solibri Model Checker, teams can detect clashes in real time, reducing material waste and repetitive tasks while significantly improving communication and coordination. So, adopting clash detection processes in the pre-construction phases is necessary for any successful construction project.

What are the major types of Clashes?

To optimize BIM clash detection, it is essential to understand the different types of clashes that can arise in a construction project. They are not all the same and have varying impacts on the model and resolution approaches. However, there are three primary types of clashes to be aware of: hard clashes, soft clashes, and workflow clashes. Each type presents unique challenges and requires specific strategies for effective management.

Hard Clashes

A hard clash occurs when two components, like structural beams and HVAC ducts or plumbing pipes and electrical conduits, occupy the same physical space in a BIM model. These clashes are the easiest to detect but can be incredibly costly if overlooked, leading to significant rework during the construction phase. Effective BIM clash detection tools and real-time model reviews help project managers and structural engineers resolve these conflicts early, ensuring smoother workflows and minimizing material waste.

Soft Clashes

A soft clash, or clearance clash, arises when building elements lack enough space for efficient operation and safety. Unlike physical overlaps, soft clashes involve indirect interference, such as insufficient buffer space for maintenance access. In MEP services, these clashes can lead to significant safety and functionality issues, including maintenance challenges and potential hazards like electrical short circuits. Many BIM professionals use effective BIM clash detection tools, like the Solibri Model Checker, to resolve these issues early, enabling timely resolutions and enhancing overall project coordination.

Workflow Clashes

A Workflow Clash, also known as a 4D clash, occurs when scheduling conflicts disrupt project timelines, leading to work stoppages, rework, and delays. Whether it’s the misalignment of electrical conduit installation with concrete pouring or premature equipment delivery, these clashes can significantly hinder on-site productivity. Leveraging BIM technology for clash detection and resolution ensures efficient scheduling and sequencing, ultimately enhancing overall project efficiency and communication among stakeholders.

Key Benefits of BIM Clash Detection:

Time and Cost Savings: Saves time and money by resolving clashes early

Enhanced Collaboration: Promotes better collaboration, communication and teamwork among different disciplines.

Reduced Material Waste: Precise planning minimizes unnecessary waste.

Improved Safety: Mitigates risks such as on-site incidents by preventing unexpected problems.

Efficient Scheduling: Ensures smoother workflow, faster project completion, and improves project scheduling and installation efficiency.

Best BIM Tools for Clash Detection

Navisworks 

Navisworks stands out as a leading BIM tool for coordination services, boasting advanced features for detecting clashes and measuring quantities, which helps in preparing models for construction.

It offers 4D and 5D simulation capabilities that not only allow for the animation and manipulation of objects but also facilitate the direct creation of schedules from models. Users can integrate schedules and financial details from external project management tools, enhancing overall project coordination.

Autodesk BIM Collaborate 

Autodesk Construction Cloud (ACC), formerly known as BIM360, is a specialized tool for enhancing Building Information Modeling (BIM) related processes, particularly clash detection.

ACC excels in facilitating BIM coordination, which is crucial for identifying and resolving conflicts in design elements before construction commences, thus avoiding costly on-site errors. The platform enables seamless data exchange between various stakeholders, ensuring that project teams can work collaboratively and efficiently from any location.

REVIZTO

Revizto stands out as a comprehensive collaboration platform that harnesses the power of advanced BIM technology. It is notable for its competent clash detection capabilities, making it an ideal choice for organizations seeking smooth integration with this function. Users can readily access Revizto from almost any location through its mobile application. It facilitates precise clash detection for specific individuals or groups and interacts seamlessly with numerous BIM and CAD systems, enhancing its versatility for various project needs.

Fuzor

Fuzor is a versatile, Virtual Design and Construction (VDC) oriented software that encompasses various editions tailored to diverse user preferences. Equipped with advanced clash detection capabilities, Fuzor allows users to perform detailed interference checks, manage proximity tolerances, and generate comprehensive clash reports.

Notably adaptable, it supports a wide array of file formats, positioning it as an ideal solution for those engaged in clash detection beyond the Autodesk environment, yet requiring integration with Autodesk file types.

Additionally, Fuzor distinguishes itself by facilitating not only the identification and analysis of clashes within project models but also by offering remediation through its innovative Live Link feature, which enables real-time model adjustments to address and resolve clashes effectively.

Solibri Model Checker

The Solibri Model Checker elevates the capabilities of standard clash detection with its advanced suite of BIM tools, including compliance and code checking, and design review functionalities. This software operates by analyzing both the geometric details and object information within a model, providing a more in-depth approach compared to conventional methods. This allows for enhanced accuracy by reducing false positives, effectively organizing clashes based on specific criteria, and facilitating detailed checks for operations, maintenance, and more.

Additionally, Solibri’s interface enables easy data sharing, being open BIM-certified, making it an efficient solution for quality assurance in BIM modeling. This comprehensive tool not only detects clashes but also offers features such as automatic export of detected issues for further analysis and handling.

usBIM.clash

usBIM.clash is a collaborative tool developed by ACCA Software, designed to identify and address both hard and interference clashes in various IFC models. Users can set basic ruleset parameters, such as comparison type, collision type, and tolerance levels, allowing them to customize the precision required for their projects. Additionally, a new module for code checking is expected to be introduced to the platform in the near future.

Conclusion:

In conclusion, as we’ve explored in this guide, the realm of BIM clash detection tools is indispensable in the modern construction landscape. Tools like Navisworks, Autodesk BIM Collaborate, and Solibri Model Checker, among others, are crucial for identifying various types of clashes that can hinder a project’s progression. Possessing the ability to pinpoint and resolve hard, soft, and workflow clashes early on ensures projects run smoother, faster, and more cost-effectively.

As BIM technology evolves, integrating advancements such as AI, machine learning, and VR/AR will further enhance clash detection capabilities, paving the way for even more precise and automated solutions. These promising developments signify a dynamic future for the construction industry, where embracing innovative BIM tools will undoubtedly lead to more efficient, collaborative, and successful projects.

Don't let costly clashes delay your dream construction project.

With our expert and industry-proven BIM clash detection services, we empower you to foresee and navigate potential clashes before they evolve into costly construction issues.

Our skilled BIM team is equipped with a featured BIM toolkit such as Navisworks and Autodesk Construction Cloud to ensure perfect alignment of every project component, which helps in reducing delays and budget overruns.

FAQs

Navisworks stands out as a leading software in the construction coordination sector, offering extensive capabilities in identifying conflicts and measuring elements within project models, ensuring they are primed for construction.
Clash detection plays a crucial role in the BIM (Building Information Modeling) process, involving the creation of advanced models that incorporate multiple models from various engineering and design disciplines.
Autodesk’s Navisworks is a popular software tool used in BIM for reviewing and coordinating projects, featuring sophisticated capabilities for identifying conflicts. It enables the integration of models from diverse design software (such as Revit, AutoCAD, and SketchUp) to conduct detailed checks for interferences among various trades.
The complexity of implementing a clash detection solution depends on factors such as the software’s sophistication, the size and flexibility of the company, and existing tech infrastructure like Building Information Modeling (BIM). Small companies and those with BIM are likely to face fewer challenges in the integration process.
Clash detection is most beneficial during the design phase of a project, ensuring designs meet specified parameters. Its use is limited in the planning phase due to the need for a completed BIM model and is less effective post-construction as it does not apply to existing structures. Essentially, while valuable, its utility is primarily during specific project stages.
Keep stakeholders updated on clash detection and resolution, starting as soon as the BIM model is ready. Document all findings and resolutions, analyze patterns in recurring clashes to target root causes, and use clear guidelines to differentiate major from minor issues. Choose software with strong integration capabilities to simplify and enhance the detection process.

Related Posts

5 most commonly used BIM Software for Data Visualization

5 Most Commonly Used BIM Software for Data Visualization

Top 5 BIM Design Tools for Efficient Construction Projects